Restaurants are starting to say no to special requests

Illustration for article titled Restaurants are starting to say no to special requests
Photo: vladko13 (iStock)
Hot LinksHot LinksWe spend way too much time on the internet

Alinea, the experimental tasting menu restaurant in Chicago, has long been accommodating of diners’ special requests. But last summer, chef-owner Grant Achatz changed its policy: no more. Well, to a point. If you’re a vegetarian or a pescatarian and notify the restaurant two days ahead of time, Alinea will adjust the menu. But if you have an allergy that can be triggered by cross-contamination or just a simple aversion to a certain food, get dinner elsewhere.


“I feel a huge obligation to please, and I find the challenge of coming up with these [adjusted] menus compelling,” Achatz told Town and Country, “but enough is enough.”

The decision came after a situation with a diner with a severe dairy allergy. The kitchen had been warned ahead of time, and all the dishes and utensils used to prepare the man’s food were specially cleaned and Achatz himself kept an eye on the meal. But the customer got sick anyway. The restaurant manager offered the man and his wife a refund or a do-over, but when it came time for the do-over, Achatz thought about it and said no. It wasn’t worth the trouble.

This story prompted Town and Country reporter Gabe Ulla to talk to other chefs around the country about their policies on special diner requests. The responses ranged from regular experimentation with ingredients that would alleviate allergies to a stubborn refusal to alter recipes. They also show a conflict between the desire to offer hospitality and exhaustion from satisfying petty demands (for instance, “alliums are okay as long as they are not visible”). A doctor claims that food allergies are real and more common than they used to be. But still, what’s a chef to do? And how can chefs and diners reach a detente? It’s an interesting read.

Associate editor of The Takeout. Chicagoan. Owned by dog.


weird question but could an allergy be counted as a disability via the ADA? I get sanitizing the entire kitchen just for a single allergen is way outside what the ADA would consider “within reason” but if you just asked “no cashews in my salad please, I’m allergic” and they refused that seems like it could fall under ADA pretty easily as it would not be difficult to accomodate.