Can plant-based foods contain eggs?

Photo: Ridofranz (iStock)

Plant-based is the new vegan, if you hadn’t heard. The two terms are mostly used interchangeably, but the phrase plant-based conjures more healthful images and, consumers say, sounds less restrictive. That’s led to the rise of plant-based everything: milk, meat, cheese, skin care products, and “chicken” nuggets.

But as Reducetarian Foundation president Brian Kateman notes in this essay for Entrepreneur, the nuggets in Tyson’s new line of Raised & Rooted plant-based foods contain eggs. Eggs may be vegetarian, but they are certainly not vegan, as they are an animal-derived product. He writes that “Tyson has taken the phrase ‘plant-based’—which means ‘contains only plants’—and co-opted it to mean ‘contains plants.’” He warns that this creates consumer confusion about what plant-based foods really are, an especially dangerous thing for an industry that’s still emerging. Because most vegans choose plant-based foods not just for health reasons but for reasons related to animal welfare, eggs from potentially factory-farmed sources are unlikely to fit with their expectations for a plant-based product. Unlike French fries, which often turn out to not be vegan because they’re fried in oil containing animal fats, Tyson’s plant-based nuggets are advertising themselves as such.

Advertisement

There is apparently no regulatory requirement for labeling foods “plant-based,” so it’s up to manufacturers to use this term in a way that’s consistent with customer expectations. Much of the debate so far about labeling plant-based foods has focused on whether non-animal-derived milk or meat alternatives can be called “meat” or “milk.” As consumers seek out plant-based foods, though, perhaps it’s time for the industry, if not the government, to step in with a verification process that defines what exactly the term includes and excludes. Readers who follow a plant-based diet, would you ever be okay with eggs in those foods?

Share This Story

Get our newsletter

About the author

Kate Bernot

Kate Bernot is managing editor at The Takeout and a certified beer judge.